Skip to main content

Evaluation of the Quality of Measurement of Diameter at Breast Height of Trees

  • Date of declaration:2023-12-29
Chyi-Rong Chiou, Chi-Ching Huang
Year
2023
Key Words
Tree inventory, quality control and quality assurance, diameter at breast height, tolerance
Abstract

Trees provide various ecosystem services. Given the impact of climate change and increasing focus on nature-based solutions, effective management of forests and urban forests is increasingly crucial. However, field tree inventory data often suffers from human errors, and there is a lack of standardized quality requirements for both data and collectors in Taiwan. A management system is needed to ensure quality control and quality assurance, and the development of tools is also needed to improve measurement precision. This study conceived an experiment to assess the measurement quality of collectors based on the number of outlier results detected using the boxplot method. We also developed a tool - breast height pole (BH pole) - to aid in measuring diameter at breast height (DBH) and evaluated its impact on measurement precision. We also conducted analyses taking into account different tree shapes and DBH classes, and proposed a suggested tolerance range. The results showed that the outlier detection mechanism facilitates rapid examination of inventory quality. When the measurement quality objective (MQO) was set to 90%, approximately 80% of collectors passed the test. Evaluation of measurement precision using standard deviation and coefficient of variation of the data revealed a high level of error in DBH inventory. The BH pole proved helpful in improving measurement precision, especially for S-type trees among the four tree types analyzed. Finally, we recommend two tolerance standards based on the results: the first utilizes the inner fence of the boxplot method, setting the tolerance as median DBH ± 0.68 cm; and the second employs standard deviation, setting the tolerance as mean DBH ± 0.56 cm. The research aimed to develop results to serve as a reference for establishing inventory quality standards in Taiwan, thereby complementing existing tree inventory guidance and regulations.